Loyalty programs are everywhere—from your favorite fast-casual lunch spots to national sit-down chains—but not all of them deliver real value. Some offer freebies frequently, while others feel like slow-burn systems that take forever to pay off. If you’re wondering which restaurant loyalty programs are actually worth it, here’s a breakdown of the best ones that consistently reward you for your appetite.
- Chipotle Rewards
Chipotle Rewards is one of the simplest and most rewarding programs out there. You earn 10 points per $1 spent, and once you reach 1,250 points, you can redeem them for a free entrée. The app also offers birthday rewards, bonus challenges for extra points, and limited-time promotions like free guac with purchase.
Pro tip: Ordering ahead through the app ensures you never miss a point—and helps you skip the line.
- MyPanera
MyPanera doesn’t use a traditional point system. Instead, it uses a personalized reward structure where you earn perks based on your purchase history. Rewards can include free pastries, drinks, or discounted meals. You’ll also get surprise offers and a birthday treat.
The program shines for coffee lovers thanks to the Unlimited Sip Club, which offers unlimited coffee, tea, and fountain drinks for a flat monthly fee—often with the first month free.
- Chick-fil-A One
Chick-fil-A One offers tiered rewards, starting with basic membership and progressing to Silver, Red, and Signature status. The higher your tier, the more points you earn per dollar spent. Points can be redeemed for menu items, and exclusive member benefits include early access to seasonal items and bonus points challenges.
Its sleek app and quick redemption options make it one of the more intuitive and generous programs.
- Starbucks Rewards
Starbucks Rewards has long been a favorite among coffee drinkers. You earn 1–3 stars per dollar depending on your payment method, and rewards start at just 25 stars. Items like handcrafted drinks, snacks, and lunch items are all redeemable, and the app frequently features bonus star challenges.
It’s particularly valuable for those who visit often and take advantage of ordering ahead through the app.
- Jersey Mike’s Shore Points
Jersey Mike’s Rewards lets you earn 3 points per regular sub and 4 points per giant sub. Once you hit 48 points, you get a free regular sub. It’s a straightforward and quick-to-redeem program, especially for sandwich lovers who eat out frequently.
Members also receive birthday offers and occasional BOGO promos through the app or email.
- Buffalo Wild Wings Blazin’ Rewards
Blazin’ Rewards earns you 10 points per $1 spent, and you can start redeeming rewards at 250 points. Redemption options range from free food to discounts on future visits. You also get points for checking in, referring friends, and watching games in-store during promotions.
The gamified experience and multiple ways to earn set this one apart from more linear programs.
- Domino’s Piece of the Pie Rewards
Domino’s Rewards is simple and consistent. You earn 10 points per order of $5 or more, and at 60 points, you get a free medium 2-topping pizza. Whether you order through the app, online, or by phone, it’s easy to track your points and see when your next freebie is due.
With frequent promotions and simple thresholds, Domino’s remains a reliable favorite for loyal customers.
What makes a loyalty program worth it?
Look for:
- Low redemption thresholds
- Frequent or flexible rewards
- Stackable savings with coupons or gift cards
- App-based ordering for better tracking and deals
Loyalty programs become especially powerful when used alongside other tools like promo codes, cashback platforms, or discounted gift cards. While this blog doesn’t cover those tools in detail, combining them with your favorite restaurant’s rewards program can significantly amplify your savings.
